The state of Britain today…….
A collection of posts on a discussion I am having on the web:
QUOTE(Crazy_Harry @ Jun 15 2006, 08:05 PM)
there’s always someone, no matter what class you are supposed to be in, who thinks they are “entitled” to something for doing nothing.
Man, you have one giant chip on your shoulder about class. Didn’t John Major tell you we are all middle class now?
QUOTE(Crazy_Harry @ Jun 15 2006, 08:05 PM)
Anyone who disagrees with that statement might want to spend some time trying to pay the rent and council tax while working a “minimum wage” job.
If you are on minimum wage then you wont have your own flat , you will be on Housing Benefit and the council will pay your council tax (or rather I will via my contribution). This is called Council Tax Benefit.
What is hard is breaking the cycle… why?, well you get a kid and suddenly your *fruitcage*ed. You cannot break the dependency because you cannot work hard enough, nor make enough money, so why bother? Just get drunk on Merrydown cider and cheap wine, serve up the turkey twislers and die young from smoking related illness.
There is only so much help you can get, in the end you have to:
a. Be good at something.
b. Work you ######s off.
The rewards of getting out the trenches?
More work! So instead you will be crippled by house prices, pay tax, insurance and credit card bills forever, work 50 hours a week and spend all weekend getting ###### on Magners cider and Cloudy Bay wine. You will have to kiss your bosses ass and finally you will die of drink related illness.
Take your pick, because I cant see much difference.
The only way to avoid a trap is to know that it exists. So, this is your trap:
LIFE.
How to avoid this trap? Simple, realise that the world doesn’t owe you a *fruitcage* thing; there are people *fruitcage* dying all over this world in absolute agony and all you have to do is find a comfortable niche in the goddamn top 3% of the world population (even higher if you have a web connection).
In other words: ENGLISH MEN! Stop feeling sorry for yourself already!
—
Reply from Carrion:
If you are on minimum wage then you wont have your own flat , you will be on Housing Benefit and the council will pay your council tax (or rather I will via my contribution). This is called Council Tax Benefit.
hate to tell you this sonny but alot of councils dont HAVE housing any more. from torbay council you will only get a council house AFTER youve had a kid, and been waiting in a bedsit for around 6 months.
also council tax benifit is a ###### to get, i know ive tried when i was earning less than £100 a week. rent was 50 so go figure if i deserved it or not. could i get any help could i bugger. all i got was well you could move back to your parents place ( i was 18 and the min wage at the time wqas 3.20 for me).
there were people on the dole actualy getting more a week than i was from basic benifits but becasue i was working it seems most of them were closed to me and if i quit then i wasnt eligable for anything at all. (there words)
as for that be good as something . im guessing you live or work in london . hers a hint you wages on AVERAGE are topped up by %20 for london weighting in an area where wages are already higher than average.
some people are managers in the westcountry who earn the same as a burger flipper in london. case point, a mate was a shift manager for tecos, he was earing in torquay a whopping 6.50 an hour. 6.50 for being a manager.
people who are good at something dont always get a job due to unemployment, lack of oppertunities (see also unemployment) and general bad luck
—
My reply :
QUOTE
a bedsit for around 6 months.
So you are not on the streets then? Right, housing, like I said.
QUOTE
also council tax benifit is a ###### to get
It is means tested, you obviously had more means.
QUOTE
there were people on the dole actualy getting more a week than i was from basic benifits but becasue i was working it seems most of them were closed to me and if i quit then i wasnt eligable for anything at all. (there words)
Ah, well, here we are agreeing with each other. It is far easier to give up and live the scummers life.
QUOTE
as for that be good as something .
Being good at something. Like something you can make money on. Could be anything. Make doilies, or paint walls, or dig drains, or run ICI; you know, whatever.
QUOTE
I’m guessing you live or work in london.
I actually live in Essex, but I do work in London. But I know all about the Torbay area in particular as my family comes from there and my Grandmother, cousins, uncle and aunt all live there still. In fact I was there a few weeks ago.
QUOTE
some people are managers in the westcountry who earn the same as a burger flipper in london.
A manager in Mc Donalds earns 25K.
http://www.mcdonalds.co.uk/jobs
QUOTE
people who are good at something dont always get a job due to unemployment, lack of opportunities (see also unemployment) and general bad luck
There is plenty of career advice out there, not only that but there are Career Development Loans, apprenticeships and part-time Uni’ courses aplenty.
Dont give me the “its tough at the bottom, you don’t know” as I come from the poorest family you can imagine.
WORK YOUR VERY SOUL TO DUST TO GET ON IN LIFE.
—
Crazy_Harry’s reply:
yeah, basho, not sure which country YOU’RE living in, but you don’t get a council house because you’re on minimum wage. Tony and Maggie sold them all off, remember?
Neither do you get a council tax break. You still have to pay council tax if you are renting a flat based on soul-or-relationship-based occupancy from a landlord.
And yes, I have a GIANT chip on my shoulder about class, its called Being an Educated Englishman.
We’ve a culture that encourages people to believe they are entitled to something for nothing, largely because of the class system. When you’ve a bunch of fat toffs living off what are eseentially state benefits, and the fattest one being Her Madge, its no wonder that we generate a society that thinks the same way.
You go somewhere that has a monarchy that actually WORKS for a living, rather than just stagger through their days making utter arses of themselves, and you’ll see a bit of a difference in terms of society…
Its all very well using the old Tory BS of “no job? get on your bike!” but I’m from a poorer-than-poor background, and both my parents did that, and so did I, but you know what, its STILL tough at the bottom, and every time YOU get one step up from it, there are ten people who YOU tread on to get there.
Sorry, I just do not buy the BS that everyone can achieve the same as everyone else in life- if that was the case, who’d pick up after you?
—
My Reply:
QUOTE
…but you don’t get a council house because you’re on minimum wage.
…Neither do you get a council tax break.
…You still have to pay council tax if you are renting a flat based on soul-or-relationship-based occupancy from a landlord.
These three things are demonstrably wrong.
QUOTE
And yes, I have a GIANT chip on my shoulder about class, its called Being an Educated Englishman.
Really, then you should know that class is simply an illusion, based on familiarity.
QUOTE
We’ve a culture that encourages people to believe they are entitled to something for nothing, largely because of the class system. When you’ve a bunch of fat toffs living off what are eseentially state benefits, and the fattest one being Her Madge, its no wonder that we generate a society that thinks the same way.
Ok, you are mixing a whole pot of things here.
QUOTE
We’ve a culture that encourages people to believe they are entitled to something for nothing,
People are entitled to a “hand up” out of despair. People are entitled to something for being an English person who needs the help.
Of course this is abused, and typically it has grown into an organic mess. People should be firmly pushed in the direction of becoming a usuful member of society.
QUOTE
When you’ve a bunch of fat toffs living off what are eseentially state benefits, and the fattest one being Her Madge, its no wonder that we generate a society that thinks the same way.
The Queen/king was once the leader in all the endevours of the country.. sadly, now they have much in common with Jordan. However, there have been times that the Queen has done great good in her position and it is clear to me that she takes the job VERY seriously. I would hardly accuse her of being lazy. Does the monarchy have a place in English future? Well, frankly I don’t like the idea of people like Blair being head of state, do you?
QUOTE
You go somewhere that has a monarchy that actually WORKS for a living
Monarchy, perhaps. Monarch, no. The Queen and Philip are definitely working monarchs. Her diary is all online and she is one busy grandmother.
QUOTE
Its all very well using the old Tory BS of “no job? get on your bike!” but I’m from a poorer-than-poor background, and both my parents did that, and so did I, but you know what, its STILL tough at the bottom, and every time YOU get one step up from it, there are ten people who YOU tread on to get there.
What can I say, I too am from a similar background and I don’t feel I have had to “tread” on anyone to get where I am. I don’t quite know in what context you mean?
QUOTE
…everyone can achieve the same as everyone else in life[?]
Everyone WILL achieve the same in life; everyone will die and everyone will have lived.
How small is the life of a man, how plain and how short? I don’t really think “position” matters in the end. Life is life. Drink it in. Fight your fights and stand up for what you wish to stand up for. You do not judge the worth of someones life by their wealth do you? Or their material worth? or their fame?
Or even their achievements?
A man who lives the whole of his life in a cave and speaks only the bats that haunt the dark recess lives EVERY BIT as worthwhile a life as you or I.
When you realise that there is no score, no leader board and no tally at the end, you realise that you are actually living your life just for you and your in built value systems. So love, if you can, hate, if you so wish, but realise that you are born alone and you die alone the bit in the middle is life.
—
More to come I am sure!












June 16th, 2006 at 5:37 pm
His reply:
hmm, Basho, leave the snippets of enlightenment to the Grand Masters, you just sound like you’ve swallowed a copy of the Tao Te Ching and its given you wind.
I don’t need you to tell me that class is an illusion, I’m not a dribbling idiot. Of course it is, but it is an illusion under which british society and culture labours. Just b3ecause something is an illusion doesn’t mean it doesn’t matter.
Perhaps I’m wrong about the minimum wage thing- things may have changed since I was last there working 50 hr weeks in a factory for buggerall, but don’t give me your psuedo-philospical tory self-made-man rubbish- sure, everyone ends up dead eventually, but we’re talking about SOCIETY, not your buddhism-for-beginners guide to existence.
I do not judge people by their monetary wealth, but rather by how they achieved that wealth
wow, I’m in fighting mode today, aren’t I? Time to get out of the office…
June 16th, 2006 at 5:38 pm
and again:
plus, when did anyone start believing John Major?
We are not all middle class, neither do we live in a meritocracy, for the bliar-ites out there. These are the sort of things put forward by people who’ve made their cash and are looking around trying to work out why they should carry on paying taxes, now they don’t need to go to uni and have a BUPA health plan (tony blair, yes, I’m talking to you- I note YOU went ot uni on a grant, and then axed them for everyone else- nice, tony, thats the spirit…)
If thats a chip, pass the curry sauce.
June 16th, 2006 at 5:40 pm
QUOTE
I don’t need you to tell me that class is an illusion, I’m not a dribbling idiot.
Your comments are making you appear an angry idiot, but I would not call you dribbling.
QUOTE
b3ecause something is an illusion doesn’t mean it doesn’t matter.
Actually, because something is an illusion means that it only matters if we let it.
QUOTE
but don’t give me your psuedo-philospical tory self-made-man rubbish- sure, everyone ends up dead eventually, but we’re talking about SOCIETY, not your buddhism-for-beginners guide to existence.
Actually I am a liberal voter. Always have been. Society is based on the mind of its members. What you call “SOCIETY”, which is a label you give to your stress of existing, is the wool of your life pulled over your eyes.
QUOTE
buddhism-for-beginners guide to existence.
Well, the beginner in this case is you and I wouldn’t call it Buddhism that I was imparting, since my philosophy is mostly made up of Nietzsche mixed with a dash of INTj and shaken very violently for 28 years.
QUOTE
I do not judge people by their monetary wealth, but rather by how they achieved that wealth
You shouldn’t judge peoples lives at all.
QUOTE
wow, I’m in fighting mode today, aren’t I? Time to get out of the office…
Me too, I have to work tomorrow (urggh!) and sunday (arrrgh!), so I am off down the pub with the wife.
June 17th, 2006 at 10:14 am
His reply:
ah, I’m sorry basho, how idiotic of me, daring to challenge your wonderful words of mighty wisdom with my peabrained analysis.
Why shouldn’t I judge people’s lives? are you telling me what to do and think? are you passing moral judgement on me? well, thats your business.
actually, something being illusional CAN mean it matters- something as ethereal as a cultural ‘illusion’ of course matters. All the stuff that we do, everyday, is all just an illusion to those who watch it- how do we know what we see is actually what is happening? we don’t we assume it is, we allow that illusion to exist as fact, and as such, it matters.
Just because you CHOOSE to exist in another form of illusion (who the hell are you to claim whats an illusion? who am I to do the same? if everything is illusion, then you can only put forward the point of view that it is illusional, as we have no actual facts on it, facts being an illusion.)
and Nietzsche? No disrespect, but thats just buddhist “everything sucks but thats ok” coupled with existentialistic “everything sucks, and I don’t care”, with a reasonable amount of smugness thrown in for good measure. Far from the most original of thinkers, though it appeals to the sort of people who like to think of themselves as separated from the very mass of humanity that bred THEM.
Amazingly, or perhaps not, cos Nietzsche certainly didn’t, you’ve not even spotted the irony of making a statement like “society is based on the minds of its members” - you couldn’t think like that if society hadn’t taught you how. To imagine it as totally apart, or that you can truly separate yourself from this existence and culture and history that mke up your reactions to events that gently shove you down the same path as Nietzsche was shoved is, just like the man himself, outrageous arrogance of the highest calibre.
and me calling your self-made-man rhetoric “tory” is in way intended to indicate that thats how you vote, just that you’ve bought some of their BS but not all of it.
enjoy the pub.
June 17th, 2006 at 10:15 am
QUOTE
ah, I’m sorry basho, how idiotic of me, daring to challenge your wonderful words of mighty wisdom with my peabrained analysis.
Thats quite all right old chap. I thought we were both giving as good as we got myself.
QUOTE
Why shouldn’t I judge people’s lives?
Judge not, that ye be not judged.
QUOTE
are you telling me what to do and think? are you passing moral judgement on me? well, thats your business.
I was proposing a maxim, in the form of my opinion; The world would be far better if people didn’t judge each other.
QUOTE
actually, something being illusional CAN mean it matters- something as ethereal as a cultural ‘illusion’ of course matters. All the stuff that we do, everyday, is all just an illusion to those who watch it- how do we know what we see is actually what is happening? we don’t we assume it is, we allow that illusion to exist as fact, and as such, it matters.
Again, this is a matter of perception. Change the perception, lose the matter. This is a matter we wish to lose. Well, I would say that; I am a skeptic.
QUOTE
(who the hell are you to claim whats an illusion? who am I to do the same? if everything is illusion, then you can only put forward the point of view that it is illusional, as we have no actual facts on it, facts being an illusion.)
The nature of knowledge is something I could go on about till the cows come home and something I am particularly concerned about.
Nietzsche? He agrees with me regarding angry judging:
QUOTE
He who fights with monsters might take care lest he thereby become a monster. And if you gaze for long into an abyss, the abyss gazes also into you.
As for the existentialists, well they turned to humanity itself to find new values. They dropped “god” morals and tried to find something human. They realised that to have stress about the world is an innate human condition, to realise that the world is not a moral place hurts if you have “god” morals.
As for Buddhists, they aim to find the “nature of reality” by rising above it.
QUOTE
Far from the most original of thinkers, though it appeals to the sort of people who like to think of themselves as separated from the very mass of humanity that bred THEM.
Why do you keep captialising words? Is it emphases? It reads as though you are spitting the words. It sounds venomous.
As for my thinking, well, all arguments start with an appeal to previous figures.
QUOTE
“society is based on the minds of its members” - you couldn’t think like that if society hadn’t taught you how. To imagine it as totally apart, or that you can truly separate yourself from this existence and culture and history that mke up your reactions to events that gently shove you down the same path as Nietzsche was shoved is, just like the man himself, outrageous arrogance of the highest calibre.
What I stand with is the thread of history. To give you a metaphor, I stand with the tide, not the crests and foam on the waves.
BS huh? Well, we are all in the end only responsible for our own behavior and bodies. What I would like is for society to teach its members the strength needed to be productive. At the moment, society is a headless chicken running around the yard. Sure, it is still moving, but it is just as dead.
I hope for a new philosophy to rescue us, just like it has done in the past. I don’t think society can be rescued by one group denouncing another, or people getting caught up in the illusion of everyday troubles. I think we must necessarily rise above the petty excuses found in todays England and strive for something. Personally, I try to do this by the methods outline in my previous posts; namely a set of realisations, a compound from which comes a feeling of being only a small dot on a small dot amongst a umpteen such dots.
QUOTE
There are some oddities in the perspective with which we see the world. The fact that we live at the bottom of a deep gravity well, on the surface of a gas covered planet going around a nuclear fireball 90 million miles away and think this to be normal is obviously some indication of how skewed our perspective tends to be, but we have done various things over intellectual history to slowly correct some of our misapprehensions… - Douglas Adams
QUOTE
enjoy the pub.
You too my friend.