I should just point out before you begin that the stuff about genetics is from “Y: The Descent of Men” by Steve Jones.
“This is your life and it is ending one second at a time” Fightclub
What does it mean to be a man in the modern world? Do men even have a place? Are men on a changing path and how long has this been happening?
Evolutionary speaking men are already a dead end. The added chromosome is an event that science knows is not going to survive into the far flung future. Geneticists all over the world know that eventually men will become something else or even disappear altogether. Women shall be the inheritors of the earth.
But why? Looking at the physical and behavioral characteristics of men shows that they are stronger and more aggressive than women. They have faster reactions and the ability to produce more power in their limbs. They have larger shoulders bigger hands and smaller hips. As my friend always reminds me they have canine teeth and a whole series of internal systems to enable them to do one thing better than women… fight.
Men are the ultimate competitor. They focus in on single confrontations far better then women. Behaviorally, they come from a line that only 10 generations ago would have had to hunt to survive. They would have had to kill to eat and fight to save them and their’s.
How has this behavior translated into the year 2005? Basically, very badly. Modern man (and by that I mean first world modern men such as an Englishman) no longer have to kill to eat. They have no need to be able to hunt or be able to fight off other men who no longer will try to steal their food. Men are civilised, urbane and docile. Still they carry their potential. Still they have their body systems and strength, but they have forgotten what it is like to fight. Men still die young, but they die less and less in battle.
So what? Well one consequence of this civilisation of men is the rise of “Total War”. The desires of the heart don’t just disappear. Men still have the urges in a true and physical way but they have no way of expressing them. Resentment and feelings of not fulfilling what it is to be a man are ever present amongst men.
But man is a clever creature and he has distilled the feelings born of hunting into activities that he can enjoy and remember when men were real-men, but at the same time be a part of the normal world.
We call these sports:
Rugby
Martial arts
Football
Wrestling
Fencing
Basketball
Airsoft
But what are the feelings and needs addressed by these sports? The truth is that they are many and not all addressed by any one sport. Many men spend years looking for activities that they can excel at and achieve release in.
For the purposes of this discussion take Airsoft. In Airsoft man is recreating a battle. Both of wills, strategy and technique. But more than this Airsoft is a brotherhood. It is a team sport. Watching men play as a team in Airsoft could be directly transposed to the ancient world as a team of men fight to kill a mammoth or battle the next tribe for land. It is a very primeval urge and need that is satisfied.
Many men look up to their family members that fought and died for their country. Myself I always think of my grandfather who was a bomber pilot in the Second World War and fought in the desert. I have a book of the time that mentions his bravery (Wings over Olympus) and I grew up staring at his medals for valor (of which he had many). What am I to do to carry on his legacy? How can I fulfill that need?
Essentially I can’t. I can of course do the normal stuff of being a good man, marrying, raising kids, staying away from drugs, etc. But what battles do I have to fight? To quote Fightclub:
“Our lives have no great battle, no great depression. Our battle is a spiritual battle and our great depression is our lives”
These words ring true for many men. In fact the entire question raised and debated in the film Fightclub (as well as the reason that it is so inordinately popular amongst men) is the pondering of this question; what is man? Essentially then, men have a part of themselves that exist as potential but is often never realised.
When I play Airsoft skirmishing I loose myself in the moment, but I am not alone. My teammates loose themselves with me. Team Recoil consists of three permanent members. Sittupking and I have been friends for over 15 years now. He is my best friend and was the best man at my wedding. Trip is fast becoming like family in the short time I have known him. The upshot of this closeness is that we very rarely need to speak to each other whilst playing. We instinctively know what the other is going to do and how he will react. For example, at the AG-05 Trip commented to me that we had just taken a doorway without saying a word to each other and automatically taken up the correct positions not crossed our movements at all. Similarly Sittupking covers my back and I his with no fear or conscious thought on my part. This is a very good feeling and addictive. It is a feeling if trust and understanding. It is a moment.
This moment of mental group focus is called Zanshin* by the Japanese. A good translation is “meditation in motion” and/or “being in the moment”. I have often felt Zanshin in Martial arts study (in fact it is a perquisite to black belt) and in my fencing. But consider that these are solo sports. Airsoft is Group Zanshin, and potent stuff capable of bringing people together and raising smiles on the most hackneyed gentlemen’s face.
So why not just play football? Why guns and combat?
Firstly, all male dominated sports are an expression of past hunting behavior and combat. Anyone who thinks basketball is non violent needs to actually play some! The enhancer for this Zanshin is pressure. Airsoft hurts. Airsoft can really hurt. Especially if you are not playing well or as part of a functioning team. Airsoft is a very high pressure, high impact sport. It demands all sorts of awareness that do not exist in more mainstream sports. It is focused in on smaller teams working closer together. The more the pressure the better the feelings of Zanshin. Similarly, Airsoft requires gentlemanly conduct. Violence and cheating are almost universally hated by Airsoft players. Anyone cheating by not taking hits is often completely rejected by the group. As is anyone overly violent. Consider that, people are shooting each other and despite the looks of their equipment they are doing it non-violently. Very rarely do you see retaliation in Airsoft. Contrast that fact with the behavior of even the highest levels of football professional!
Secondly, most Airsoft people do play normal sports as well. Simple. Very few people have only Airsoft. I myself fence, paint, write and practice Taekwondo. I love to cook, read and visit my friends. Airsoft is a facet, not the whole. As the Buddha said, “All things in moderation”. This also means not denying oneself!
Thirdly and most importantly, Airsoft is also a collectors sport. Airsoft guns are techy’, nerdy and eminently collectable. Not to mention all the other equipment that goes along with it. There is a definite part of most, if not all men, that loves technical equipment that functions well. The endless question of “what am (is the) best gun?” This lends a whole structure to Airsoft, where a player is not just judged by his skills but also by his equipment. This means that Airsoft has an open social structure. A player can become “cooler” simply by having something particularly interesting or unusual. This gives rise to the “geardo” sub-culture of collecting the most expensive and realistic equipment.
As long as men feel disenfranchised in their lives, things like Airsoft and paintball will be needed. They perform a useful release mechanism for the players, not to mention the health benefits of running around and jumping over things. They allow for safe team play and the building of social structures whilst at the same time don’t require much in the way of investment by the person. Have gun and mask, will play. There is the almost infinite specialist and uniqueness of each and every Airsoft player’s load out and kit bag. There is also the gentlemanly way Airsoft has to be played.
In all these aspects Airsoft is good. But it is in the high expressions of Zanshin and brotherhood that really sets it apart. For this, Airsoft is truly great.
Basho
*Zanshin is used as a term all over the martial arts and does not translate well to English. To fully understand my take on it read “Meditation and the mind in modern martial arts”












August 5th, 2005 at 4:55 pm
project_jam
Jul 14 2005, 06:51 PM
you wrote alot lol good points to
A* lol
JAM
mhe
Jul 14 2005, 07:21 PM
I regularly get weird looks if somebody finds out how i prefer to spend my free time (airsofting in the woods with friends and my team), and until now I never hat a truly great explanation for them. Thanks for pointing out why airsoft makes perfectly sense in a way that cannot be denied by even the blindest of those opposing our sport smile.gif
(and sorry for my probably bad english, not my native language wink.gif)
Sam1626
Jul 14 2005, 07:28 PM
Wow………………
I do fencing(#57 in mount-haynes foil at the public schools championship) but I never realised about all that Zanshin stuff………..then again (going off airsoft here) anyone whosed fenced propely knows that you get an “itch”when you’ve parried a blow telling you the exact time to riposte.Is it basicly that?
Anyway back to airsoft I haven’t experienced any of that stuff in airsoft.Proboblay because I haven’t played as much.
by the way +1 for comitment wink.gif
elrey
Jul 14 2005, 07:32 PM
Pretty interesting theory. I agree.
Ou811
Jul 14 2005, 07:33 PM
Very nice, and indepth +1
gunyo89
Jul 14 2005, 07:37 PM
i think i sort of understand you on the part of u knowing where your freinds are and how to move.
its like at the start of the urban charge matches i didnt mind running straight in to the enemys fire because i knew the rest of the team were behind me. is that sor t of zanshin? im not sure
Basho
Jul 14 2005, 07:38 PM
QUOTE(Sam1626 @ Jul 14 2005, 07:28 PM)
Wow………………
you get an “itch”when you’ve parried a blow telling you the exact time to riposte.Is it basicly that?
Yes mate thats it. I get it all the time in fencing as you never have time to think and have to allow your body to work totally seperate to yourself.
It is a faculty of the mind I call ” The little maths genius”
Zanshin is great stuff. It is where G. Lucas got his ideas of the force from (in that case the Zanshin of Akido). It is the body acting in the moment on total instinct. It is also a very happy place to be.
Zanshin means “the remaining mind” This is the mind of completing an action. It is the moment of bliss after scoring a hit. The moment of concentration as you pull the trigger. Living in the moment is like breathing. You don’t think about it, you just do. In and out. Like the feeling in your mind that we have only one life,
Fightclub:
“This is your life and it is ending one second at a time”.
It is complete follow through and release. No hesitation or feeling of pushing yourself past any hesitation.
The swordsman Musashi called it “the void” in “the book of five rings”. Samurai had it in spades of course.
Anyway, group Zanshin is the rare feeling if being in total tune with others. I have felt it only at certain times (such as… ahem… sex) but also and much more often in airsoft (Of course, I have more clothes on in airsoft!).
It’s good stuff.
Sam1626
Jul 14 2005, 07:51 PM
I see…..but that means,if your correct,I lose myself without thinking about losing myself……..arg,the brain it hurts.
Quote:All humans LMG start in life as a blank canvas, we are born with no conscious knowledge of math. We can’t tell the time, add up or subtract:End
Not according to ancient greeks.According to them we have all the knoledge of the world already stored in our brain we just need to discover it.
Basho
Jul 14 2005, 07:53 PM
QUOTE(Sam1626 @ Jul 14 2005, 07:51 PM)
I see…..but that means,if your correct,I lose myself without thinking about losing myself……..arg,the brain it hurts.
Quote:All humans LMG start in life as a blank canvas, we are born with no conscious knowledge of math. We can’t tell the time, add up or subtract:End
Not according to ancient greeks.According to them we have all the knoledge of the world already stored in our brain we just need to discover it.
*
Not to diss the ancient Greeks but A Priori knowledge (the type you are talking about) is ######s smile.gif
Monk
Jul 14 2005, 08:02 PM
QUOTE(Basho @ Jul 14 2005, 12:53 PM)
Not to diss the ancient Greeks but A Priori knowledge (the type you are talking about) is ######s smile.gif
*
I do agree on this point.
Frankly, I really like the original post. Good to see other intellectualize the sport. There has to be so much more than simply the desire to run around in the woods getting hit with pellets.
I finish games feeling sore, worn out, and absolutely thrilled. It taps a primal need. When I get home, I switch gears (no pun intended) and think about gear and tactics, consider my moves and clean my gear while planning the next upgrade. Airsoft touches on the intellectual, the physical, and the primally emotional.
Oh, and I like guns.
trip
Jul 14 2005, 08:15 PM
as always basho does it again putting into word what most other couldn’t
many thx wink.gif
Billy210
Jul 14 2005, 08:43 PM
QUOTE
Oh, and I like guns.
Amen.
Lovely bit of writing Basho, I know what you mean by Zanshin. The Japanese seem to have every little facet of the subconscious covered by some word or phrase.
I’m not too happy about the ‘Man will die out’ bit though…smile.gif